here are my two rebel commander's are they both Ledy?can someone who know's chime in gracious.Dan.

Hi dan,

left one is ledy....right one not I would say.

See there are three different RCs with the same coo.

dont have my figures here so...anyone else?

Wolff

I'd say the left is Ledy and the one on the right is not.

I need to go out now so I'll have a good look tonight, but you can see by the face colour and the colour of the scarf coming down over his shoulder.

burnsy wrote:

I'd say the left is Ledy and the one on the right is not.

..., but you can see by the face colour and the colour of the scarf coming down over his shoulder.

I second that.

Uli

Motion thirded (or fourthed)...looks like glossy black details on the left too to go with the reddish mo.

I may be crazy but they both look good. At first glance I thought the black back was glossy but maybe it is just the pic or just me. Head band looks right, emblems look good. Facial hair is the only difference. Coo is kinda the last thing I look at with the RC but that matches also. What am I missing???

Jason

sacko wrote:

I may be crazy but they both look good. At first glance I thought the black back was glossy but maybe it is just the pic or just me. Head band looks right, emblems look good. Facial hair is the only difference. Coo is kinda the last thing I look at with the RC but that matches also. What am I missing???

Jason

jason...look at the scarf color!

Also facial is the important one! As I said...there are three different RC with the same coo. All three have nearly same black, glossy, etc. color.

MOST IMPORTANT ON THIS ONE IS FACIAL....must be redish! AND THE SCARF COLOR!!!!!

Wolff

wbobafett wrote:

sacko wrote:

I may be crazy but they both look good. At first glance I thought the black back was glossy but maybe it is just the pic or just me. Head band looks right, emblems look good. Facial hair is the only difference. Coo is kinda the last thing I look at with the RC but that matches also. What am I missing???

Jason

jason...look at the scarf color!

Also facial is the important one! As I said...there are three different RC with the same coo. All three have nearly same black, glossy, etc. color.

MOST IMPORTANT ON THIS ONE IS FACIAL....must be redish! AND THE SCARF COLOR!!!!!

Wolff

Yes I do see the color on the facial hair now . Also the shape is a little different correct? I have 2 I will be taking pics of tonight to post.

Jason

so what is the one on the right PBP?Dan

The RC PBP is this....no a common figure....

wow,javi do you have one like that for sale.

No C.O.O. Rebel Commander

yo rob,i actually have two different variant's of that same figure no coo,too rob i know everyone think's my rc figure on the left is Ledy but what do you think of the one next to it.it has same coo and same color painted yellow boot's.could it be a ledy variant of the variant?Dan

Dan, the one on the right (R/C) has totally different colour boots, the frontal images have too much light to compare detail too, Ledy on the left, the one on the right isnt Ledy, i dont know his origin perhaps a variant expert can help on that one.

Guys,

I have almost the exact same figure I wanted to post. I have 2 in the pics below. Left is Ledy and the right is that figure. Glossy black but standard color hood and boots. Same coo. The shape of his mustache also matches ledy although not the bright red. My standard (still carded) RC has matte black colors and a shorter mustache. Anyways we know there are variants within ledy like the CCP, how do we not know that this isn't also a ledy variant? I was sold mine as a ledy also. Here are the pics.



Thanks

Jason

i just took a real good look at my figure's and jason's their both identical.my Ledy rc is the same.and the variant rc is the same.i have to think these are ledy.

vintageSWfan wrote:

i just took a real good look at my figure's and jason's their both identical.my Ledy rc is the same.and the variant rc is the same.i have to think these are ledy.

On what evidence Dan?

The figure on the left is Lili Ledy 100% but the figure on is in question at this stage.

I have highlighted some points to look at on your picture and added some MOC pictures for reference -

good pic's and investigative work jay.maby it's not a possibility it could be ledy not known,or maby it's a variant of something else i'm not sure..i know the mustache on my second figure is'nt pure red like the 100% ledy but it it is slightly brown/red.the coo is the same as ledy too.it has the made in stamp on right leg and the same datestamp on the left.it has to be something.jason and i both have the same one's.and it is different than a no cco because of the made in stamp is like the ledy.does anyone know what it is.wolff maby.i'd like to see if he can post the three pic's up of all three different ones with the same leg stamp's as both leg's have.and were there from that would clear all the confusion,must have pic's though.front and back of all three variant's.Dan.

Thanks for those Jay. It appears to me that the scarf in the first MOC is not grey but a brown? I think what Dan and I are asking is could there possibly be a variation of Ledy. If not a variation of ledy what is it? With toys this old the best we can do is guess . Has anyone pulled a no coo, fat mustache (slightly red), glossy black paint RC from a card?

Jason

sacko wrote:

Thanks for those Jay. It appears to me that the scarf in the first MOC is not grey but a brown? I think what Dan and I are asking is could there possibly be a variation of Ledy. If not a variation of ledy what is it? With toys this old the best we can do is guess . Has anyone pulled a no coo, fat mustache (slightly red), glossy black paint RC from a card?

Jason

Thats what i was thinking as well Jason.

The colours arent to great on some of those MOC pictures but i cleaned them up the best i could.

For me the easiest way to check the left figure is the same as the moc examples but the figure on the right isn't is by the boot colour.

Jay

I'm too lazy to read through this RS post again, but he's discussed in here http://threads.rebelscum.com/showflat.php?Cat=&Number=2174493&page=&view=&sb=5&o=&fpart=2&vc=1

aussiejames wrote:

I'm too lazy to read through this RS post again, but he's discussed in here http://threads.rebelscum.com/showflat.php?Cat=&Number=2174493&page=&view=&sb=5&o=&fpart=2&vc=1

Yep i knew it had been discussed before the figure on the right is not a Lili Ledy but a European NO COO Variant which is more common than the actual LL Rebel Commander and is passed off as LL by various sellers out there.

The big give away is the boots.

Jay

To add a further quote from the same figure been discussed on RS the other year -



" gustie wrote:

Idefix13 wrote:
Sorry Gustie no Ledy.

The Ledy RC has darker boots and a red-brown moustache. The figure you have is an European no coo variant so you can remove Chewie's bowcaster.


Uli



Ha ok thanks - i can give him his rifle back then.

you often say european variant - but what is this exactly?




this are figures made by european companies as the spanish pbp, dutch clipper, french meccano or the palitoy. those where the cardbacks, not from Kenner. there are sometimes some differences in the moldings off the loose figures between those kenner or the european produced figures. not quite as big variations as the mexican lili ledy or brazilian glasslite, but there are some common variants in those european lines. I think the RC that you where showing is an pbp ^*correction* German rebel commander, but i could be wrong. i am just in the variation collecting, but i am sure others here on the forum can give you more specifics about this if you need.

greetz Dennis. "

My latest MOC purchase will prove the origin of the figure on the right

sacko wrote:

Guys,

Ayways we know there are variants within ledy like the CCP, how do we not know that this isn't also a ledy variant? I was sold mine as a ledy also. Here are the pics.


Thanks

Jason

hi jason:

!. did you bought the one from the right from mexico???? I think not!

2. there is no carded proof of another ledy version

3. the one on the right can be get everywhere......I can surf through ebay and show you 20 auctions with this figure!!!

Believe me and the rest of us: the right one is 100% not Ledy!

Wolff

Hi guys,

one more thing.....


DONT GO FOR THE LEFT INSIGNIA...the black 2 things on the body.....there are different version: splitted and painted together...BOTH LEDY!!!

ONLY thing to be sure is msutache color and scarf color (also boots,,, but thats difficult from pic)

SEE PICTURE:


Wolff